In 2016, Ann M. Martin (Babysitters Club, Main Street, lots of other things) joined forces with the original author's great-granddaughter to create Missy Piggle-Wiggle, Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle's niece.
There are some differences from the original series. Mr. Piggle-Wiggle, who was always a pirate but was deceased in the first books, is now alive and Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle goes off in search of him. Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle lived in an upside down house, which she sold in the third book to move to a farm, and then ended up back in the house in the fourth book with no further mention of the farm. Now the farm and upside down house have been combined, though the farm really plays no role in any of the three modern books.
Missy Piggle-Wiggle (yeah, kinda low-hanging name fruit) is the niece of Mrs. and she comes from a magical school that I'd be interested in reading more about. She takes on Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle role as a friend to children who also assists with magical cures when need be.
The Whatever Cure introduces Missy and the animals Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle left in her care, then jumps right into chapters devoted to different children receiving different cures. The flavor of the original books remains, though with a modern twist. There's also the amusement of the names. The original series had some very interesting names, although a lot of them were also perfectly normal. I think there's more of a skew towards unusual names in the new series, though a handful of the kids have relatively normal names. My favorites from the original are Paraphernalia Grotto and Pergola Wingsproggle, while the new ones I like best are Honoriah and Petulance Freeforall, Edwina Nevermore, Almandine Clavicle and Roseate Spoonbill. Then there's a bit of romance added to it with Missy's growing relationship with bookseller Harold Spectacle.
This is the strongest book of the three.
Won't Walk the Dog is the second in the series and came out in 2017. This one opens with a storm that destroys portions of the upside down house, causing Missy to worry about finding a source of money.
The strongest cures are Won't Walk the Dog and Woe Is Me.
The book ends with Missy finally locating the silver key Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle told her to find. Turns out it's a huge solid gold key painted silver. So Missy's money worries are over.
The third and possibly final book came out in 2018, but I only just finished reading it a couple days ago.
This is by far the weakest with a lot of the cures having very similar styles. Three of them involve making the people around the child behave in the same way as the child so they're forced to see what a problem they've been. This is fine and amusing, but also very repetitive when they're three chapters in the same book and neither of the other two books really had any cures like this. Won't Walk the Dog sort of was, but it was way more entertaining when it was an anthropomorphized dog, so it's a bit different. A fourth chapter has a multi-stage cure that has a final stage where other people are suddenly given the power the child was given, so that's another similar instance. Sticky Fingers is the best cure by far (and the kid has two moms).
The main story of this one, not involving the cures, is that the upside down house is stricken with the Winter Effluvia, which sometimes is a basic illness and other times causes interesting problems. Lightfoot the cat floats through the air, while Penelope the parrot speaks in commercials. Missy quarantines the house so the kids can't come in.
Another thing I didn't care for with this book was how cowardly Harold is. He's very quick to basically flee once Missy realizes it's the Effluvia. They have a sweet moment at the end, but it's different than the Harold that's been more helpful in the first two books.
Despite nitpicking, I really did enjoy all three of these and I wish there was another one coming!
No comments:
Post a Comment