I was excited to find this book in one of the local antique malls, though I didn't buy it there. They tend to be a bit pricey, so I plug the info into Amazon and yep, almost $6 cheaper.
I love the format of this series. Each volume opens with an introduction and then a non-fiction essay about the title character. Then there are several fiction short stories for the latter part of the book. Sounds pretty great, right?
I started with Circe's book, because she's the one who found me that day. At first, I enjoyed the essay, but ended up annoyed by it. It was a rambling, unorganized mess, divided into nonsensical sections that sometimes were just the literal continuation of what came before with no needed break for a new heading. It was extremely repetitive. I felt like I read the same sections and topics multiple times. My biggest issue though was the author's constant reference to Madeline Miller's Circe novel. It's fine to devote a section of your essay to Miller's novel, but there were so many repeated references to the novel that it felt like the author was treating it on the same level as ancient sources. You couldn't tell where she was talking about the book and where she was talking about ancient myths.
Thankfully, the short stories were mostly fun. I liked a lot of them, though there were some that took a darker turn on things. There are always going to be those authors that want every interaction in ancient myth to become a rape story. Sometimes that's definitely the take from the ancient sources, but not always, and it does get as repetitive as the opening essay. Sometimes it's handled well and I'm sure there are audiences that enjoy this sort of viewpoint. I'm not here for mopey, weak Circe though. My favorites were the ones with a different take on her relationship with Scylla, the one where she was a badass in modern times, and the one where she's younger and sculpting animals out of clay.
I'm looking forward to the other nine volumes in this series, which I'll be tackling in alphabetical order. In late October, we're getting Helen of Troy (Can we move away from Troy then, please? Achilles and Odysseus already have books in the series and now Helen.) and...drumroll...GILGAMESH. I hope to see Egyptian, Hindu, East Asian, more West Asian, and American mythology take the spotlight in future volumes, but I'm sure we've got plenty of Greeks left to go, as they've mostly done mortals so far.
















